Backdoor Roth pro-rata calculator
Why a backdoor Roth is rarely tax-free, how much of it is actually taxable, and the one move that fixes it.
- Taxable portion
- ·
- Non-taxable portion
- ·
- Share that escapes tax
- ·
- Pre-tax money in your IRAs
- ·
- Tax if rolled into a 401(k), basis converted
- ·
Point at any line to see what it means.
What this is actually calculating.
A backdoor Roth is a non-deductible contribution to a traditional IRA followed by a conversion. People expect it to be tax-free, because the contribution was made with money already taxed. It usually is not.
The IRS does not look at the account you contributed to. It aggregates every traditional, SEP and SIMPLE IRA you own and taxes the conversion in proportion to how much of that total is pre-tax. Contribute seven thousand alongside a ninety-three thousand pre-tax IRA and only seven percent of the conversion escapes, no matter which account the money physically left.
The parts that decide the answer.
It is a denominator problem
The taxable share is decided by your total IRA balance, not by the account you used. Shrink the pre-tax part of that total and the arithmetic changes completely.
A 401(k) is the usual fix
Pre-tax money rolled into an employer plan leaves the IRA aggregate entirely, because 401(k) balances are not counted. Do that first and the same conversion can be entirely tax-free.
Which balance to enter
The balance you expect in all your traditional, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs on December 31, after this conversion. Form 8606 adds back what you convert, so the calculator adds it for you. Include any pre-tax money you will roll into an IRA later in the year: a 401(k) rolled into an IRA in June still counts against a conversion made in February.
Not every account counts
Your traditional, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs are aggregated. Roth balances, 401(k)s, inherited IRAs and your spouse's IRAs are not.
Before you rely on it.
Does my spouse's IRA count?
No. The aggregation is per person, so a spouse's balances are irrelevant to your calculation, and each of you is measured separately.
What if I convert more than my basis?
Anything above the basis is taxable regardless. The pro-rata rule decides how the basis is spread, not whether the excess is taxed.
Can I still do this if my 401(k) will not accept a rollover?
Then the pro-rata result stands. Some plans do not accept incoming rollovers, and a solo 401(k) is sometimes the answer for an owner. That is worth confirming before contributing.
Get your results as a PDF
A branded summary of the figures you entered, what they mean, and the assumptions behind them.
Downloaded. A copy is on its way to your inbox.
A number is a starting point, not a plan. The next step is a conversation about what it means for yours.
Book a Free CallA complimentary 30-minute call. No cost, no obligation, and nothing to prepare.
Keep Reading
From the blog
How to Appeal an IRMAA Surcharge the Year Your Income Drops
Medicare's IRMAA surcharge uses your income from two years earlier, so a big exit year keeps billing you after the income stops. If you retired or sold, file Form SSA-44, check work stoppage, attach proof, and give Social Security an honest estimate of your new, lower income.
Read MoreDeferred Compensation Plans: How the Election, Payout and Risk Really Work
A nonqualified deferred compensation plan lets you put off pay, and the income tax on it, well beyond what a 401(k) allows. The trade is that you choose when it pays out years in advance, and the money stays a promise from your employer. Here is how the elections, payouts, taxes and risk work.
Read MoreHow Are RSUs Taxed? Why the Withholding Falls Short, and Whether to Sell at Vest
RSUs are taxed as pay on the day they vest, whether or not you sell. Here is how the tax works in 2026, why the 22% your company withholds is often thousands short, the cost basis mistake that really does tax you twice, and how I think about selling at vest.
Read More