Roth conversion calculator
Whether paying tax now beats paying it later, and the future tax rate at which the answer flips.
- Tax due on the conversion now
- ·
- Roth value when you draw on it
- ·
- If you did not convert, after tax
- ·
- Plus the tax money, still invested
- ·
- Not converting, all in
- ·
- Breakeven future tax rate
- ·
Point at any line to see what it means.
What this is actually calculating.
A conversion moves money from a traditional IRA to a Roth and you pay income tax on it now instead of later. The whole decision reduces to one comparison: the rate you pay today against the rate you would have paid on withdrawal. Everything else is arithmetic around that.
Where the tax comes from is the input people leave out, and it changes the answer more than anything else. Paying it from other savings puts the full amount to work tax-free, so converting wins even when the two rates are identical, provided the tax money would have earned less after tax outside the Roth. Paying it out of the conversion means only what is left after tax makes it across, and then converting is a wash unless your future rate is higher.
The converted amount is added to your taxable income for the year you convert and taxed at your ordinary rates, stacked on top of your salary, pension, Social Security and everything else. It is not a capital gain and it cannot be spread over several years. That stacking is why the size of a conversion matters: the first dollars may be taxed at 12 or 22 percent and the last at 32.
The breakeven works like this. If you pay the tax out of the conversion and your tax rate is the same now and later, the two paths finish exactly level, because taking 24 percent off at the start or at the end of the same growth leaves the same number. So converting only wins when your future rate is higher than today's, or when you pay the tax from money outside the account. The calculator shows the future rate at which the two paths meet, and you judge which side of it you are likely to land on.
Your future rate is often higher than people assume. Required distributions start at 73 or 75 and rise each year, Social Security can become up to 85 percent taxable, and a surviving spouse moves from joint to single brackets on roughly the same income. Children who inherit a traditional IRA generally have to empty it within ten years, often in their own peak earning years. Each of these pushes the future rate up and the breakeven in favour of converting.
There are two five-year rules. Each conversion starts its own five-year clock: take converted money out before it ends while you are under 59 and a half and the 10 percent early withdrawal penalty can apply to it. Separately, earnings in a Roth come out tax-free only once you are 59 and a half and at least five years have passed since you first funded any Roth IRA. If you are over 59 and a half and have had a Roth for five years, neither rule is likely to bite.
A conversion also raises the income Medicare looks at. Part B and Part D premiums carry an income-related surcharge, IRMAA, set from your tax return two years earlier. For 2026 it starts above $109,000 of modified adjusted gross income for a single filer and $218,000 for a married couple filing jointly; the thresholds are indexed, so a 2026 conversion is tested against 2028's. A conversion at 63 can raise premiums at 65. It is not a reason to avoid converting, but it belongs in the sizing.
I go through the 2026 brackets and a worked example of a couple filling a bracket on purpose in my Roth conversion guide, linked beside this section.
The parts that decide the answer.
No state tax is modelled here
A conversion is taxed by your state as well, in the year you do it, and the state you retire to may tax withdrawals differently or not at all. Moving from Pennsylvania, which does not tax retirement distributions, to a state that does, or the reverse, can matter more than the federal rate this compares.
The breakeven rate is the real output
Not the dollar figure, which depends on a return nobody knows. The breakeven is the future tax rate at which converting stops paying, and you can judge whether your own rate is likely to land above or below it.
A conversion can raise your Medicare premiums
Converted amounts count toward the income that sets IRMAA surcharges two years later. A conversion sized without checking that can cost more in premiums than it saves in tax.
Filling a low bracket beats converting it all
Most of the value comes from converting just enough to use up a low bracket in a year when income is down, often between retiring and starting Social Security or required distributions.
Each conversion has its own five-year clock
Converted amounts generally have to season five years before they can be withdrawn without penalty if you are under 59 and a half. That matters if the money is needed soon.
Take any RMD before converting
Once required distributions have started, the first dollars out each year count toward the RMD, and an RMD cannot be converted. Take the full distribution first, then convert what you planned on top.
After-tax money brings the pro-rata rule
If any of your traditional, SEP or SIMPLE IRAs hold after-tax contributions, every conversion is partly taxable and partly not, in proportion across all of them. You cannot choose to convert only the after-tax dollars. The backdoor Roth calculator works out that split.
Heirs pay the tax at their rate
Most children who inherit a traditional IRA must empty it within ten years, often while earning the most they ever will. A Roth inherited the same way comes out tax-free. If the money is more likely to be left than spent, the future rate that matters may be theirs, not yours.
Before you rely on it.
Can a conversion be undone?
No. Recharacterising a conversion was removed in 2018, so the decision is final once made. That is the argument for converting in measured amounts rather than all at once.
What future tax rate should I use?
Your expected marginal rate in the years you would actually withdraw, not your rate today. Required distributions, a surviving spouse filing single, and Social Security becoming taxable all push it up more often than people expect.
Does this account for state tax?
No, and Pennsylvania treats retirement income differently from most states. Fold your state rate into the two rate fields, or ask your CPA before acting on the result.
How is a Roth conversion taxed?
As ordinary income in the year you convert, added on top of your other income for that year. Any after-tax basis in your IRAs comes across tax-free in proportion. There is no 10 percent penalty on the conversion itself, but if you are under 59 and a half and have tax withheld from it, the withheld part is treated as a withdrawal and can be penalised.
What is the five-year rule for Roth conversions?
Each conversion has its own five-year clock, starting on 1 January of the year you convert. Withdraw converted money before it runs out while under 59 and a half and the 10 percent penalty can apply. A separate clock, starting with your first Roth contribution or conversion, decides when earnings come out tax-free after 59 and a half.
Will a Roth conversion increase my Medicare premiums?
It can. Medicare's IRMAA surcharge is based on your income from two years earlier, and for 2026 it starts above $109,000 of modified adjusted gross income single or $218,000 joint. A conversion that crosses a threshold raises Part B and Part D premiums for a year, so I size conversions with those lines in view.
Is there a limit on how much I can convert?
No. There is no income limit and no cap on the amount. The practical limit is the tax: because the whole conversion is income in one year, converting too much at once can push it into a higher bracket than you would ever pay later.
When does a Roth conversion make sense?
When your tax rate now is lower than you expect it to be when the money comes out. The years between retiring and starting Social Security or RMDs, a year with a business loss, and a year of unusually low income are the usual windows. It makes less sense if you need the money within five years or expect a lower rate in retirement.
Can I do a Roth conversion after RMDs start?
Yes. Take that year's required distribution first, because it cannot be converted, and then convert any amount on top. Converting in your seventies also shrinks the balance future RMDs are calculated on.
Get your results as a PDF
A branded summary of the figures you entered, what they mean, and the assumptions behind them.
Downloaded. A copy is on its way to your inbox.
A number is a starting point, not a plan. The next step is a conversation about what it means for yours.
Book a Free CallA complimentary 30-minute call. No cost, no obligation, and nothing to prepare.
Keep Reading
From the blog
How to Appeal an IRMAA Surcharge the Year Your Income Drops
Medicare's IRMAA surcharge uses your income from two years earlier, so a big exit year keeps billing you after the income stops. If you retired or sold, file Form SSA-44, check work stoppage, attach proof, and give Social Security an honest estimate of your new, lower income.
Read MoreDeferred Compensation Plans: How the Election, Payout and Risk Really Work
A nonqualified deferred compensation plan lets you put off pay, and the income tax on it, well beyond what a 401(k) allows. The trade is that you choose when it pays out years in advance, and the money stays a promise from your employer. Here is how the elections, payouts, taxes and risk work.
Read MoreHow Are RSUs Taxed? Why the Withholding Falls Short, and Whether to Sell at Vest
RSUs are taxed as pay on the day they vest, whether or not you sell. Here is how the tax works in 2026, why the 22% your company withholds is often thousands short, the cost basis mistake that really does tax you twice, and how I think about selling at vest.
Read More