Executive Compensation · November 18, 2026

How Are RSUs Taxed? Why the Withholding Falls Short, and Whether to Sell at Vest

RSUs are taxed as ordinary income when they vest, not when granted. Why the 22% withholding often falls short, how to avoid paying tax twice, and when to sell.

An executive in a navy suit sits back in a leather chair, looking at a laptop on a conference table.
When RSUs vest, the tax is owed that day, whether or not you sell a single share.

RSUs in one paragraph

A restricted stock unit is a promise from your employer to give you shares (or their cash value) once you meet a condition, usually staying for a set time. Until then you own nothing: no shares, no vote, no dividends. When the units vest, the company delivers the shares, and at that moment they become pay. Most public companies vest RSUs quarterly or annually over three or four years. Many private companies use double-trigger RSUs, which need both time served and a liquidity event (a sale or IPO) before they settle.

When RSUs are taxed: at vest, not at grant

The grant itself is not taxed. Nothing happens on your tax return the day you receive the award letter.

The tax arrives on the vesting date (more precisely, the day the shares are delivered, which is usually the same day or within a few days). The value of the shares that day is ordinary income, exactly like a cash bonus:

  • Federal income tax at your ordinary rates, up to 37% in 2026
  • Social Security at 6.2%, until your total wages for the year reach $184,500 in 2026
  • Medicare at 1.45%, plus the 0.9% Additional Medicare Tax on wages above $200,000 (single) or $250,000 (married filing jointly)
  • State and local tax, which for Pennsylvania residents means the 3.07% state rate plus your local earned income tax

The vest-date value becomes your cost basis in the shares, and your holding period starts the next day. You owe the tax whether you sell the shares or keep them. That is the single most important thing to understand about RSUs: by the time you decide whether to hold, the tax bill already exists.

One thing RSUs do not allow is an 83(b) election. That election, which lets you pay tax at grant instead of vest, applies to restricted stock, not restricted stock units. If someone suggests it for your RSUs, ask them to look again at the grant type.

Are RSUs taxed twice?

Not really, and this is the question I hear most. There are two separate taxable moments, but they tax two different things.

Moment What is taxed How it is taxed
Vest The full value of the shares that day Ordinary income (on your W-2)
Sale Only the change in price since vest Capital gain or loss

If the shares vest at $100 and you sell the same day at $100, you have $100 of income and no gain. If you hold and sell at $130, the extra $30 is a capital gain: short-term (taxed like ordinary income) if you held one year or less, long-term (0%, 15% or 20%, plus the 3.8% net investment income tax for higher earners) if you held more than one year. If you sell at $80, you have a $20 capital loss.

The mistake that does tax you twice

There is one way RSUs genuinely get taxed twice, and it is a paperwork error. The Form 1099-B your broker sends after a sale sometimes shows a cost basis of zero, or leaves it blank, because the $100 of income was already reported on your W-2 instead. If your return uses that number, you pay capital gains tax on the full $100 that was already taxed as pay.

The fix is on Form 8949: report the correct basis (the vest-date value) and use adjustment code B. Your stock plan administrator’s supplemental statement or year-end tax packet usually shows the right figure. Every year, I check this line on clients’ returns with their CPA, because a single quarter’s vest with the wrong basis can add thousands of dollars of tax nobody owed.

Why the withholding at vest is often short

When your RSUs vest, your company has to withhold tax. Most do it by selling or holding back some of the shares (“sell to cover” or “net settlement”). The federal rate they use is not your bracket. RSU income counts as supplemental wages, and for 2026 the IRS lets employers withhold a flat 22% on supplemental wages up to $1 million in the year, and requires 37% on anything above $1 million.

If your income puts you in the 32%, 35% or 37% bracket, 22% is not enough. The gap does not disappear; it arrives in April, sometimes with an underpayment penalty on top.

A 2026 worked example

Meet an executive, married filing jointly, with $400,000 of salary and bonus. In 2026, RSUs worth $250,000 vest across four quarters. To keep the math simple, the couple takes the $32,200 standard deduction and has no other income.

  • Without the RSUs, their taxable income is $367,800, inside the 24% bracket.
  • The RSUs push taxable income to $617,800. The first $35,750 is taxed at 24%, the next $108,900 at 32% and the last $105,350 at 35%.
  • Federal income tax on the RSUs: $80,300, an average of about 32%.
  • Federal tax withheld at 22%: $55,000.
  • Shortfall: $25,300, due when they file.
Executive, $400,000 of salary, $250,000 of RSUs vesting in 2026 Amount
Federal tax withheld on the RSUs at 22% $55,000
Federal income tax the RSUs actually add $80,300
Shortfall due in April $25,300
Average federal rate on the RSU income 32.1%
Bar chart: on $250,000 of RSUs vesting in 2026 for a married executive with $400,000 of salary, the company withholds $55,000 of federal tax at 22%, but the RSUs add $80,300 of federal income tax, leaving $25,300 due in April.
The flat 22% left this executive $25,300 short at tax time.

If the same executive had $1.25 million of RSUs vest in the year, the company would withhold $312,500 (22% on the first $1 million, 37% on the rest), but the RSUs would add about $447,300 of federal tax. The shortfall grows to about $134,800, because 22% applies to most of the income while almost all of it is taxed at 35% or 37%.

How to close the gap

  1. Ask whether your plan allows a higher withholding rate. Some plans let you elect more than 22% on RSU vests (up to 37%). Many do not, so check before assuming.
  2. Raise your regular paycheck withholding with a new Form W-4. The IRS treats withholding as paid evenly through the year, so extra withholding in November and December still counts.
  3. Make quarterly estimated payments. If you plan to pay this way, set the amounts in the spring, not after the fourth vest.
  4. Use the safe harbor. You generally avoid the underpayment penalty if your withholding and estimates cover 110% of last year’s tax (when last year’s AGI was over $150,000). A tax projection each fall tells you whether you are inside it.

I build that projection with every executive client before the last vest of the year, because the cheapest time to fix a shortfall is before it becomes a penalty. My tax planning work is built around it.

Should you sell RSUs as soon as they vest?

Here is the test I use. If your company paid you this amount as a cash bonus, would you use the cash to buy your company’s stock? Keeping vested RSUs is the same decision. You have already paid the income tax on them. The only question left is whether this is the right investment for that money.

Taxes are rarely a reason to hold. Selling right at vest creates little or no extra tax, because the price has barely moved from your basis. Holding for more than a year only gets the lower long-term rate on growth after vest; it does nothing for the income already taxed. Holding is a bet that this one stock will beat a diversified portfolio by enough to justify the risk.

Reasons it can make sense to sell at vest:

  • Your job and your investments already depend on the same company. If the stock falls, it often falls at the same time as bonuses, raises and job security.
  • The position keeps growing on its own. Each quarter’s vest adds more. Many executives I meet have far more company stock than they would ever choose to buy, simply because they never decided to sell.
  • You have a goal that needs the money: a home, college, paying down debt, or reaching the point where work is optional.

Reasons people keep some shares:

  • Ownership guidelines. Many public companies require officers to hold a multiple of salary in company stock.
  • Conviction plus capacity. If your plan works even if the stock is cut in half, holding a portion is a choice you can afford.

There is no single right percentage. As a starting point for the conversation, many planners treat company stock above 10% to 20% of your net worth as concentrated. The goal is a share of your wealth you can live with in a bad year for your company, which is how I approach concentrated stock for clients.

Rules that apply to executives

If you are an officer or have access to inside information, you can usually sell only during open trading windows. A Rule 10b5-1 trading plan lets you set up future sales in advance so they can happen even during blackout periods. Since SEC rule changes that took effect in 2023, a new plan for a director or officer has a cooling-off period before the first trade: the later of 90 days or two business days after the company reports its results for the quarter, up to 120 days. That makes a plan something to set up months before you need it, not the week a big tranche vests.

Other RSU details worth knowing

Selling at a loss near a vest can trigger the wash sale rule. If you sell company shares at a loss within 30 days before or after a new tranche vests, the vest counts as buying replacement shares. The loss is disallowed for now and added to the basis of the new shares. It is not lost forever, but it may not land in the year you wanted it.

Retirement-eligible employees can owe FICA early. Some plans let RSUs keep vesting if you retire after a certain age and service. Once you meet that test, the units can be subject to Social Security and Medicare tax before the scheduled vest, even though income tax still waits until delivery. Your pay stub may show FICA on shares you have not received yet. That is usually correct, not an error.

Moving states splits the tax. If you lived or worked in more than one state between grant and vest, each state can usually tax its share, often based on the days you worked there during that period. Plan the move with your CPA before the next vest.

Unvested RSUs usually disappear when you leave. Before you accept a new offer, add up what you would forfeit and ask the new company to replace it.

How Modern Wealth can help

For executives, RSUs are rarely a one-time decision. They arrive every quarter, they change your tax bill every year, and they quietly build a concentrated position. On my executive compensation work, I map every vest for the next few years, project the tax before each one lands, set a selling plan (including 10b5-1 plans where you need one) and decide where the proceeds go, coordinated with your CPA and your company’s plan administrator.

Frequently asked questions

Are RSUs taxed when granted or when vested?

When they vest (more exactly, when the shares are delivered). The grant itself is not taxed. On the vesting date, the value of the shares is ordinary income on your W-2.

Are RSUs taxed as ordinary income?

Yes, at vest. The value of the vested shares is wages, subject to federal and state income tax, Social Security (up to the annual wage base) and Medicare. Later growth or loss after vest is a capital gain or loss.

What is the withholding rate for RSUs?

Most employers withhold federal tax at a flat 22% on RSU income, and 37% on supplemental wages above $1 million in a year. State tax, Social Security and Medicare are withheld too. The 22% rate is often lower than an executive’s real bracket.

Should I sell RSUs as soon as they vest?

Often, yes, unless you have a specific reason to hold. Selling at vest adds little tax, since your basis equals the vest-date value. Ask whether you would buy the stock with a cash bonus of the same amount; if not, holding is a choice to keep more risk in one company.

Should I sell RSUs or ESPP shares first?

Usually compare the tax cost of each lot. RSU shares sold soon after vest often carry little gain. ESPP shares can qualify for better tax treatment if you hold them two years from the offering date and one year from purchase, so selling them early can cost more. A lot-by-lot review with your CPA settles it.

How are double-trigger RSUs taxed?

They are taxed when both conditions are met, usually at the company’s sale or IPO, on the value of the shares at that point. Because many years of vesting can settle at once, the income can be very large in a single year, which makes a tax projection before the event especially important.

Can I avoid tax on RSUs?

Not the income tax at vest; it is pay. You can manage it: give appreciated shares (held more than a year) to charity or a donor-advised fund, harvest losses elsewhere, raise retirement plan deferrals to lower other taxable income, and make sure your 1099-B basis is correct so you do not pay twice.

This article is for general education and is not tax, legal or investment advice for your situation. Talk with your tax and legal advisors before acting.

Sources

← All articles

Ready to put this into practice?

Let’s talk about your business, your goals, and the planning it takes to connect them.