Quick Answer
Medicare's IRMAA surcharge uses your income from two years earlier, so a big exit year keeps billing you after the income stops. If you retired or sold, file Form SSA-44, check work stoppage, attach proof, and give Social Security an honest estimate of your new, lower income. If that income lands under $109,000 single or $218,000 joint for 2026, the surcharge goes away entirely.
After retirement lowers your income, a quiet moment at the kitchen table is a good time to review your Medicare premiums.
How do you appeal an IRMAA surcharge the year your income drops?
You file Form SSA-44, check one life-changing event (usually work stoppage), attach proof that you retired or sold, and give Social Security an honest estimate of this year's income.
What you need
- Your IRMAA determination letter from Social Security
- Form SSA-44, which has three main pages to fill out
- Your latest Form 1040, for line 11 (adjusted gross income) and line 2a (tax-exempt interest)
- Proof the work stopped: an original signed employer statement, final pay stubs, or original or certified documents of your business transfer
- A realistic estimate of this year's income, ideally checked with your accountant
Steps to file
- Read your letter and note which tax year Social Security used. FinanceWonk's 2025 guide explains that 2026 premiums come from 2024 income, so your exit year can follow you for a while.
- Choose one life-changing event. Retiring, or stepping out of the business you sold, goes under work stoppage. Check one box only; extra boxes do not help your odds.
- Enter the date your work stopped or your hours dropped.
- Report the lower income. Add line 11 and line 2a for the year your income fell. If that year is the current one, enter an estimate; you prove it later with your tax return.
- Estimate next year's income if you expect it to be lower again, along with your filing status.
- Attach your proof. If you have none of the documents above, a signed statement made under penalty of perjury is accepted.
- Submit the form in person at your local Social Security office by appointment, or send it by fax or mail. Keep copies of everything, stored somewhere safer than one more app (here is why your stack of finance apps is a growing fraud surface).
- Refile next year if the two-year lookback still lands on a high-income year before you stopped working.
Common mistakes
- Treating the sale gain as the event. Michael Kitces noted back in 2013 that a liquidation triggering a large capital gain is not necessarily eligible for an exception, so you build the request around the fact that you stopped working, not around the windfall.
- Checking several boxes. Pick the single event that fits and that your paperwork actually proves.
- Lowballing the estimate. FinanceWonk's 2025 guide points out that going over a bracket by even $1 brings the full surcharge for that tier, so estimate honestly and let your accountant check the math before Social Security does. If you plan a Roth conversion this year, put it in the estimate too.
Social Security compares your estimate with your tax return later. It has a longer memory than most of us. At Modern Wealth, retirement and tax are two of the eight planning service areas we cover, which is why I'd rather your SSA-44 estimate and your tax plan come out of one conversation instead of two. If you want more background first, our frequently asked questions page covers how I work with owners.
Frequently Asked Questions
What do people ask after filing Form SSA-44?
Do I get back the higher premiums I already paid?
Usually, yes. Social Security's own publication says you should receive a refund of overpayments once your request is approved. Keep paying in the meantime so your coverage stays clean.
What if Social Security turns down my request?
Medicareresources.org notes that an appeals process exists when your finances have changed. The next step is a Request for Reconsideration, filed on Form SSA-561-U2, which Kitces pointed to back in 2013 for situations outside the standard list. Read the denial letter first, because it spells out your options.
Do I have to file again next year?
Often, yes. IRMAA is recalculated every year, and the two-year lookback can still land on your last full working year. Think of it like renewing a parking permit: last year's sticker does not count for this year, however well you parked.
Written by
Alan Rhode, CFP®, CPWA®, CVGA®, CEPA®, RLP®
Founder & CEO | Private Wealth Advisor
Alan Rhode, CFP®, CPWA®, CEPA®, CVGA®, and RLP®, is Founder & CEO | Private Wealth Advisor at Modern Wealth, an independent, fee-only fiduciary firm.
Connect on LinkedIn